
Released: 2018
Genres: Pop Rock, Synthpop, Electropop, Alternative Dance, Synthwave
The Musiquarium’s Simulation Theory Review Score: 2.5/5
Following 2015’s Drones, which was a more consistent album than The 2nd Law, but less adventurous, Muse goes in a new direction by jumping on the recent eighties revivalism bandwagon, which was catalyzed by the television show, Stranger Things (also evident by the album art).
The opener, Algorithm, is one of the best songs here, continuing Muse’s penchant for starting off all their albums on a high note. The momentum continues with the similarly eighties-sounding Dark Side. Pressure goes in a more glam rock direction, though it’s still one of the better tracks on the album. The robotic voice on Propaganda is unintentionally hilarious, and then the song goes into some Prince-like cosplay.
Break It to Me kind of sounds like something that would play in a futuristic, cyberpunk strip club, and is actually one of the more successful experiments on Simulation Theory. Something Human is one of the worst offenders here, sounding like generic late 2010s pop, rather than something from a skilled, progressive rock trio like Muse. Thought Contagion is the most radio-friendly song here, with an admittedly catchy chorus, though it sounds awfully close to something from a shitty band like Imagine Dragons.
Blockades returns to the darker synthwave sound of the first couple of songs, though it’s not particularly memorable. Dig Down sees a return to Imagine Dragons style pop rock, but unlike Thought Contagion, it’s one of Muse’s worst songs yet. Get Up and Fight is another dud, with a cheesy optimism to it and these cringe-inducing female backing vocals. The Void fortunately wraps up the album with a similar sound to the opener.
Simulation Theory is a mixed bag, with some of Muse’s most adventurous songs yet, but also some of their worst too. Had they stuck to the dark synthwave sound, it’d have made for a stronger and more consistent album, but there are just too many failed pop experiments sprinkled throughout, which keep it from a higher score.
For credit breakdowns and historic release details, view Muse on Discogs.
Back to the 2018 Album Reviews Guide or the Muse Reviews page.
Written by Brett Nippard
Leave a Reply