
Released: 2005
Genres: Progressive Rock, Art Rock, Latin Rock, Experimental Rock, Psychedelic Rock
The Musiquarium’s Frances the Mute Review Score: 5/5
After finding success with their unique and chaotic brand of progressive rock on 2003’s De-Loused in the Comatorium, The Mars Volta had two options they could have pursued on their next album: ease into a more commercial and accessible sound or go in an even more experimental direction — the band boldly chose the latter and crafted an album that, while not necessarily better than its predecessor, was arguably even more ambitious than it was.
The title track was unfortunately omitted from the final album, as its inclusion would have resulted in the album exceeding the time limit of a CD, but it is just as essential as the rest of the tracks. The actual opener, Cygnus….Vismund Cygnus, is an epic with many moving parts and tempos and has an ambient electronic ending, which Omar Rodriguez-López has shown a penchant for since the At the Drive-In days.
The lead single, The Widow, is a haunting ballad with a wonderful Cedric Bixler-Zavala vocal. The song is one of the band’s greatest pop moments, giving further proof of the dynamism that prog bands have been able to achieve ever since the beginning of the genre’s roots, with resident ballads appearing as early as on prog’s first opus, King Crimson’s In the Court of the Crimson King (in this case, Epitaph). Flea of Red Hot Chili Peppers appears on the trumpet on this song.
Speaking of Chili Peppers, John Frusciante also returns from De-Loused, featuring on L’Via L’Viaquez, providing two guitar solos; the song also incorporates slowed down salsa sections sporadically, and allow’s the band to indulge in its Hispanic roots. Miranda That Ghost Just Isn’t Holy Anymore is the album’s Moonchild — there is great beauty in the ambience and weightlessness of the song.
That brings us to Cassandra Gemini, a gargantuan track, which was supposed to be one ~32 minute long song, but Universal twisted the band’s arm and made them edit it down into eight short songs. Despite the bastardization of the songs, it still condenses the ideas of an entire album into one piece and is one of Omar Rodriguez-López and Cedric Bixler-Zavala’s greatest compositions. The album ends with the acoustic motif that commenced the album, tying up the concept nicely.
Frances the Mute is a masterpiece of a sophomore album and one of the greatest modern prog rock albums.
For credit breakdowns and historic release details, view The Mars Volta on Discogs.
Back to the 2005 Album Guide or The Mars Volta Reviews page.
Written by Brett Nippard
Leave a Reply