The Strokes – First Impressions of Earth | Album Review


The Strokes First Impressions of Earth review artwork on The Musiquarium

Released: 2006

Genres: Post-Punk Revival, Garage Rock Revival, Indie Rock

The Musiquarium’s First Impressions of Earth Review Score: 3.5/5

With vocalist Julian Casablancas having been the sole songwriter for every song on Is This It and Room on Fire (other than an Albert Hammond Jr. co-write on Automatic Stop), First Impressions of Earth features a handful of songs co-written by the rest of the band, signalling a kind of burnout from the frontman.

Gordon Raphael, who produced The Strokes’ first two albums, was initially supposed to produce all of First Impressions of Earth as well, but after David Kahne was brought into the studio to co-produce, Raphael eventually stepped down. Where The Stroke’s first two albums had a lo-fi charm, First Impressions of Earth sounds comparatively flat and dull, lacking in much of any dynamic. Moving on from Gordon Raphael as producer may have been necessary for the band to grow and evolve, but it makes for a transitional album that sounds significantly worse than its predecessors.

As for the songs themselves, You Only Live Twice is one of the band’s best and most uplifting singles, lead single Juicebox brings on a killer surf rock guitar riff, and Heart in a Cage has Julian Casablancas doing his best Iggy Pop impression. The chorus to Razorblade sounds suspiciously like Barry Manilow’s Mandy, but then again, Is This It‘s title track sounded a bit like Pixies’ Where Is My Mind? and Last Nite sounded like Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers’ American Girl. Ize of the World has some of the album’s best guitar work. Ask Me Anything is a minimalistic song with nothing but what sounds like a synthesizer and Casablancas’ voice.

First Impressions of Earth may not be timeless like Is This It or as much fun as Room on Fire was, and it suffers from weaker production and some bloat at 14 tracks long, but it is still a fairly good album, with some great singles and musicianship, with plenty to offer across its 14 song tracklist.

For credit breakdowns and historic release details, view The Strokes on Discogs.

Back to the 2006 Album Guide or the The Strokes Reviews page.


Written by Brett Nippard


Discover more from The Musiquarium

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Published by


Leave a Reply